Reviews moved to COED

[yourself]

Why are reviews like these moved to COED?

Review: Sweet talker..

A reason given on that thread is "the rules" but I cannot find such a rule.

IMO, If there was enough deception/miscommunication where one of the parties walks, this is relevant and belongs in the review section.

If both parties meet face to face: It is a review. maybe no ROS credit, but should still remain as a review

[Duke of G]

Actually, it's "did the session take place" that is the standard for "is this a review?"

If no activities (beyond a meeting at a door, or other contact) happen, then it's not supposed to be a review.

YMMV on specifics, but that's the general standard.

[Namssa]

I have, over the years, meet several ladies face to face without a session. So if we were to use the that as a guide it could mean we would have to guess at the intent of the face to face meeting. Too subjective and too many clicks here to allow that subjective of reason to classify it as a review. It is easy to define by did BCD take place, if so then it is a review, as Duke has explained above.

Thanks for the question.

[yourself]

Duke, I do not see this "did the session take place" rule published anywhere on this site. Could you please provide a link? Even if it exists, do you really think it is reasonable?

Namssa, there is a big difference between running into someone at a social and booking a session.

No Activities? If a guy wasted hours of his time contacting a provider, booking a session, getting money, driving to an incall, the door opens and he walks because instead of Salma Hayek he he was greeted Rosanne Barr.... you are saying there was "no activity"..

Wouldnt you find this information more useful than some guys accounting of how many times he popped in an hour?
Do you really want to make it easier for people who make their bait and switch tactics so bad that a client walks away?

okay,...so if you guys really think you are doing the right thing, then be consistent about it. Why is it that you only move SOME of those reviews to COED? What is so different about THIS REVIEW where there were "no activities" by your definition and unlike the one that just got moved, no money was paid?.

[Guest022315]

So will these reviews get moved to coed No service took place in carla review but she got paid and in jersey case she did not show up but they did communicate

http://eccie.net/showthread.php?t=844410

http://eccie.net/showthread.php?t=845002