Imo it's as simple as a deal is a deal. I've never given discounts for reviews...I like them but not enough to give discount for a guy to write one.
BUT when I see threads like this about guys not honoring their end of a review special/discount it makes me think it might be better to apply it to the 2nd or later date. In my head hopefully the guy is planning to repeat anyways and when he does he can pay discounted rate then. Karma doesn't find some of these guys fast enough that are essentially ripping ladies off. Long reply short +1 to Kat's 2nd post

.